Issues

• Inside a mark's content, marks are sorted and de-duplicated but an empty marks: [] is not omitted — item 3's three clauses come apart

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#138 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Sep 4, 2026

• A vector with no expectedId is COUNTED AS A PASS, not skipped: "384/384 passed, 0 skipped" with the document ID never compared

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#137 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Sep 4, 2026
  1

• §4.3.1 items 2 and 3 are keyed on element SHAPE, not position: a text-shaped object anywhere gets mark normalization — a false REJECT and a silent ID collapse

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#136 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Sep 4, 2026
  1

• definedId keys namespace membership on element shape, not position — a live document-ID collision and a type/@type split

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#132 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 31, 2026
  1

• A block index cannot describe id-less top-level blocks, and blockCount does not say which form it counts

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#130 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 30, 2026

• A text-node id escapes both the uniqueness check and the canonical-name prohibition

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#129 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 30, 2026
  1

• check:block-content-positions: derivation gaps, a cardinality floor, and its own central property unpinned

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#127 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 29, 2026
  2

• The attributes barrier stops at the merge: id-namespace membership, rewriting and reference resolution are inconsistent

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#125 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 29, 2026
  2

• §4.3.2 number arm is raw-scoped where spec and published vocabulary both say hashed (false REJECT on crdt)

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#123 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 28, 2026

• §4.3.1 item 4 and §4.3.2 item 2 are keyed on element shape, not position — and the obvious fix has a regression

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#121 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 28, 2026
  5

• Config-slot hash bindings can be silently lost, and closing it needs a specification decision first

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#120 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 28, 2026

• Coverage residue from PR #118: checks that exist but do not reach part of their population

  Entrolution/cdx-file-format-spec#119 · Filter by author gvonnessi opened on Aug 28, 2026